The film is about the difficulty of maintaining a solid relationship in modern times. Eight married college friends plus one other non-friend (all of whom have achieved middle to upper class economic status) go to Colorado for their annual week-long reunion, but the mood shifts when one couple's infidelity comes to light. Secrets are revealed and each couple begins to question their own marriage
[Perry] makes it easy on us, mostly by letting his cast do what it wants.
– Wesley Morris,
Boston Globe,
15 Oct 2007
fresh:
Despite the improbable ease of pic's genteel psychoanalysis, the characters are thesped with enough depth and emotional investment to make their problems feel legit.
– Ronnie Scheib,
Variety,
16 Oct 2007
rotten:
None of these flaws will matter much to Perry's devoted audiences, whose support has enabled him to virtually build a media empire.
– Frank Scheck,
Hollywood Reporter,
16 Oct 2007
fresh:
Amid the shout-downs over adultery, male power, and the agony of coping with a child's death, one performance glistens -- Jill Scott's as the sad, heavyset Sheila, who locates the faith that's the source of love.
– Owen Gleiberman,
Entertainment Weekly,
17 Oct 2007
rotten:
Faulting Tyler Perry for his nonsensical, melodramatic plots is a little like accusing Douglas Sirk of using too much color.