A withdrawn young man, Leland Fitzgerald is imprisoned for the murder of a mentally disabled boy, who also happened to be the brother of his girlfriend, Becky. As the community struggles to deal with the killing, Pearl Madison, a teacher at the prison, decides to write about Leland's case. Meanwhile, others affected by the murder, including Becky and her sister, Julie, must contend with their own problems.
Besides being puffed up with its importance, it's also inert and totally implausible -- one of those movies where nobody behaves in a way that seems remotely human.
– Ruthe Stein,
San Francisco Chronicle,
9 Apr 2004
rotten:
[Hoge] spends an awful lot of time trying to get us to understand Leland and almost none trying to get us to understand his victim.
– Mike Ervin,
Chicago Reader,
9 Apr 2004
rotten:
It's neither an insightful nor well-made film.
– Liam Lacey,
Globe and Mail,
9 Apr 2004
rotten:
Isn't it sad that a boy like this could feel so lost that he had to kill someone? Well, maybe. But isn't it sadder that someone's dead?
– Stephen Whitty,
Newark Star-Ledger,
9 Apr 2004
fresh:
An intriguing movie about how badly we really want to know the unknowable, what makes kids kill other kids.