Reporter John Klein is plunged into a world of impossible terror and unthinkable chaos when fate draws him to a sleepy West Virginia town whose residents are being visited by a great winged shape that sows hideous nightmares and fevered visions.
Pellington knows, as did the 1940s master of horror Val Lewton, that what you don't see can raise far more goose bumps than what you do.
– David Ansen,
Newsweek,
29 Sep 2008
fresh:
This is the scariest movie I've ever seen.
– Lisa Alspector,
Chicago Reader,
11 Jan 2008
rotten:
Director Mark Pellington hardly lets a moment pass without suggesting some bad vibes creeping onto the edges of the screen, but he's let down by Richard Hatem's script.
– Robert Koehler,
Variety,
11 Jan 2008
rotten:
There are certainly strong moments and efficient set pieces here, too, but for all the claims that the film, adapted from a 1975 book by John Keel, is based on real events, Pellington fails to sustain credibility.
– Wally Hammond,
Time Out,
9 Feb 2006
rotten:
Despite hints that it aspires to be more, The Mothman Prophecies is a by-the-numbers sci-fi thriller.