It's filthy, nasty, sexy, absurd, appalling, and exhilarating, and it succeeds as a musky union of novelist Cormac McCarthy's bleakness and Ridley Scott's sense of chic.
– Wesley Morris,
Grantland,
10 Dec 2013
rotten:
A great writer's pompous idea of pulp fiction, treated with stultifying seriousness by everyone else involved.
– Guy Lodge,
Time Out,
12 Nov 2013
rotten:
Each scene serves as little more than an index card for the mechanistic plot, which Scott films in a glossy and fluid style befitting an industrial promotion for the movie's high-tech weaponry.
– Richard Brody,
New Yorker,
4 Nov 2013
rotten:
The Counselor is the cumbersome end product of a high-minded writer trying to slum and a slick director aiming for cosmic depth.
– Sam Weisberg,
Village Voice,
28 Oct 2013
rotten:
It's not so much a bad film as it is a disappointing one. A very disappointing one.