The scariest aspect of "The Boy" is the extent to which Macneill makes it possible to sympathize with the troubled protagonist -- even as its haunting final shot hints at the horrors yet to come.
– Eric Kohn,
indieWIRE,
10 Aug 2015
rotten:
While it's admirable that director Macneill and his co-scripter Clay McLeod Chapman opted to emphasize mood and psychology over the story's more exploitable elements, it nonetheless results in a listless tedium.
– Frank Scheck,
Hollywood Reporter,
10 Aug 2015
rotten:
While the score goes out of its way to make his every action feel sinister, the picture doesn't fulfill its horrific potential until the third act.
– Sherilyn Connelly,
Village Voice,
12 Aug 2015
rotten:
The film feels overly long, and while lingering shots of the mountain scenery do help convey the isolation of the deserted motel, too many of them feel repetitive.
– Devan Coggan,
Entertainment Weekly,
18 Aug 2015
fresh:
Mr. Macneill and his co-screenwriter, Clay McLeod Chapman, have developed a feature stunning to behold if somewhat unpersuasive in narrative.