Miss Potter is as seamless, comfortable and tidy as a Peter Rabbit story, all scones and biscuits, quietly punctuated by tolerable naughtiness.
– Michael Booth,
Denver Post,
9 Mar 2007
rotten:
One of those films that commits few egregious errors, but scales few real heights. There is nothing either terribly wrong or keenly right about it. It's tidy, I suppose.
– Robert Denerstein,
Denver Rocky Mountain News,
9 Mar 2007
rotten:
The film offers scant insight into the forces that inspired Potter's phenomenally successful career.
– Colin Covert,
Minneapolis Star Tribune,
8 Mar 2007
rotten:
If the source material is soft, the film then takes another punch with the casting of Renee Zellweger in the title role. She overflows with tics and twitches that make the author seem vaguely deranged.
– Randy Cordova,
Arizona Republic,
8 Mar 2007
fresh:
With Miss Potter, Renee Zellweger has won back that precious thing that stardom rips away and the tabloids won't let you reclaim: her charm.