The coincidences are almost all supremely transparent and the characters gratingly quirky, two faults that committed acting almost redeems. But not quite.
– Matt Weitz,
Dallas Morning News,
16 Dec 2004
fresh:
The performances are solid, even when the roles are aggressively whimsical.
– Colin Covert,
Minneapolis Star Tribune,
29 Nov 2004
fresh:
You can see what's coming five minutes into the movie, but capable acting lends it a certain superficial charm.
– Ella Taylor,
L.A. Weekly,
4 Nov 2004
fresh:
Warm-hearted but clear-eyed indie effort richly repays audience patience during deliberately paced and provocatively allusive early scenes with a cumulative emotional impact that is immensely satisfying.
– Joe Leydon,
Variety,
4 Nov 2004
rotten:
An overly ambitious, overly complex and overly long opus that bites off more than it can chew.