Vittoria avoids discussing the crime for which Abu-Jamal spent 29 years in solitary confinement on death row, instead tracing the path of a brilliant journalist whose message cannot be silenced.
– Ronnie Scheib,
Variety,
1 Feb 2013
fresh:
"Mumia" gradually becomes a persuasive attempt to celebrate the content of his character, not the violence that apparently led to his imprisonment.
– John Hartl,
Seattle Times,
21 Feb 2013
rotten:
A film that would let us decide the pros and cons of his life for ourselves would certainly be welcome.
– Kenneth Turan,
Los Angeles Times,
28 Feb 2013
fresh:
Director Stephen Vittoria lines up a roster of writers and educators, actors and activists, to sing Abu-Jamal's praise. And praise they do.
– Steven Rea,
Philadelphia Inquirer,
3 May 2013
rotten:
More of a tribute than a hard-hitting piece of American filmmaking, which is too bad, because the subject - the imprisonment of ex-Black Panther figure Mumia Abu-Jamal - deserves a thorough, serious examination.