The arrival of a newborn girl causes the gradual disintegration of the Cairn family; particularly for 9-year-old Joshua, an eccentric boy whose proper upbringing and refined tastes both take a sinister turn.
Ratliff's movie almost succeeds in hurtling over the trenches it digs for itself in an increasingly ludicrous third act. But not quite.
– Geoff Pevere,
Toronto Star,
13 Jul 2007
rotten:
The contrived script expects us to believe that Joshua's fainting spells, his nocturnal home videos of his sleeping family and his acts of violence on crowded New York City streets fail to raise suspicion until it is too late.
– Colin Covert,
Minneapolis Star Tribune,
19 Jul 2007
fresh:
The nerve-shattering ending will have you hugging your children when you get home - but only if there are witnesses present.
– Sean Means,
Film.com,
3 Aug 2007
fresh:
As horror flicks go this is both smart and suspenseful.
– J. R. Jones,
Chicago Reader,
3 Jan 2008
fresh:
...a bewildering extension rather than a retread of this played-out subgenre.