Ollie Trinke is a young, suave music publicist who seems to have it all, with a new wife and a baby on the way. But life deals him a bum hand when he's suddenly faced with single fatherhood, a defunct career and having to move in with his father. To bounce back, it takes a new love and the courage instilled in him by his daughter.
The script stoops to cheap gags that undercut Affleck's efforts to sustain a believable character.
– Joe Leydon,
Variety,
23 Jun 2008
rotten:
The grating sense of commercial calculation in Jersey Girl consistently undercuts Smith's fine writing.
– J. R. Jones,
Chicago Reader,
27 Mar 2004
fresh:
Inspired by Smith's own awe and amazement at being a father, the movie is modest and entertaining, with a minimum of sentimental goo, and it demands little of us except a good-natured willingness to go with it.
– Stephanie Zacharek,
Salon.com,
27 Mar 2004
rotten:
The filmmaker drowns his trademark edgy stew of smutty humor, stiff acting and dime-store insight into human nature with a gravy of glutinous bathos, making for a singularly unpalatable dish.
– Michael O'Sullivan,
Washington Post,
26 Mar 2004
rotten:
This kind of weepy material works in the hands of melodrama masters like Douglas Sirk or Pedro Almodovar. But here, it's over-the-top and it's just horrible.