If "Henry's Crime'' is occasionally too pleased with itself, it's also pleasantly unpredictable, and it has a trio of sweet hambone performances at its center.
– Ty Burr,
Boston Globe,
21 Apr 2011
rotten:
A felony of a movie ... tedious and improbable...
– Michael O'Sullivan,
Washington Post,
22 Apr 2011
rotten:
What's needed is someone nervous to play Henry. A Steve Buscemi, for example. Reeves maintains a sort of Zen detachment.
– Roger Ebert,
Chicago Sun-Times,
28 Apr 2011
fresh:
Go for Caan and Farmiga, and stay to be surprised by Reeves.
– Bill Goodykoontz,
Arizona Republic,
28 Apr 2011
rotten:
An intermittently entertaining comedy/drama with a funny script and a fatal miscasting.