Lee draws his lines between fantasy and reality without much confidence and with only a sketchy logic.
– Jonathan Rosenbaum,
Chicago Reader,
1 Jan 2000
rotten:
While Lee is a skillful director, he's also more coldly analytical than emotional, and it is not his style to get us to feel for this woman as much as we should.
– Kenneth Turan,
Los Angeles Times,
14 Feb 2001
rotten:
Lee has done the impossible: He's sucked the fun out of call-in sex and replaced it with sanctimonious prattle.
– Peter Travers,
Rolling Stone,
12 May 2001
rotten:
Lee's never been too hip to women's perspectives, and in Girl 6, he proves that marriage, maturity and 10 years of filmmaking haven't substantially corrected his blind spot.
– Edward Guthmann,
San Francisco Chronicle,
18 Jun 2002
rotten:
[Randle] holds the film together as best she can with her luminous presence and dignity, but can't supply the lacking subtext, past history and motivation.