This one seethes with authentic nostalgia; Wilder's attempt not merely to eulogize earlier styles but to revive them feels somewhat embalmed.
– Richard Brody,
New Yorker,
5 Sep 2014
rotten:
Wilder may have been a genius, but not everything a genius does is a work of genius. Fedora is a curiosity, not a lost masterpiece.
– Stephanie Zacharek,
Village Voice,
2 Sep 2014
rotten:
The deliberate and sometimes dismaying anachronisms are signs of a deep, unshakable commitment to a personal aesthetic -- a commitment that is sometimes more moving than anything in the film itself.
– Dave Kehr,
Chicago Reader,
14 Aug 2007
rotten:
Trust Wilder to know what he's doing, even during the deliberate cliches. See it like that, and I bet you'll like it. See it with a straight face, and you'll think it's boring and obvious.
– Roger Ebert,
Chicago Sun-Times,
23 Oct 2004
fresh:
Fedora is old-fashioned with a vengeance, a proud, passionate remembrance of the way movies used to be, and a bitter smile at what they have become.