Best buddies Acerola and Laranjinha, about to turn 18, discover things about their missing fathers' pasts which will shatter their solid friendship, in the middle of a war between rival drug gangs from Rio's favelas.
Along comes a sequel of sorts, City of Men, but the difference is clear right from the first frame: Meirelles is gone and so is the intensity. What's left is a mix of credible sociology and tired melodrama, along with a palpable sense of deja vu.
– Rick Groen,
Globe and Mail,
29 Feb 2008
fresh:
The story might have been lifted from an old Warner Brothers melodrama, though it's smartly paced, sincerely delivered, and consistently absorbing.
– J. R. Jones,
Chicago Reader,
29 Feb 2008
rotten:
Where City of God was ferocious, grandiose, and glamorous, this movie is modest and intimate, acoustic where the other was desperate to electrify.
– Wesley Morris,
Boston Globe,
29 Feb 2008
fresh:
[It has] a real ring of authenticity in every scene.
– Richard Roeper,
Ebert & Roeper,
10 Mar 2008
fresh:
It plays like a Western, and the violence, while plentiful and visceral, rarely has the kind of raw impact you want in a movie such as this. Morelli keeps most of the blood off-camera.