A sensitive and beautifully made lesson in the limits and power of storytelling.
– John DeFore,
Hollywood Reporter,
10 Sep 2016
fresh:
There's a truly monstrous film lurking in here somewhere, but Bayona seems hell-bent on keeping it at bay.
– Tom Huddleston,
Time Out,
10 Sep 2016
rotten:
A splendidly rendered, yet oddly ill-conceived terminal-illness melodrama that feels much too dark and serious for audiences Conor's age, and an even more curious fit for grown-ups.
– Peter Debruge,
Variety,
11 Sep 2016
fresh:
Considering how easily the material could turn maudlin, it's especially notable that Bayona avoids overstatement.
– Eric Kohn,
indieWIRE,
6 Oct 2016
fresh:
It tries hard to simultaneously be exciting, emotional and magical. And while it doesn't always manage to nail that tricky trifecta, it provides a number of touching moments and a behemoth to remember.