Set in 1944 France, an American Intelligence Squad locates a German Platoon wishing to surrender rather than die in Germany's final war offensive. The two groups of men, isolated from the war at present, put aside their differences and spend Christmas together before the surrender plan turns bad and both sides are forced to fight the other.
Despite such peculiarities, or perhaps because of them, A Midnight Clear has a quirky, haunting quality, delivering good performances all around, but especially from Sinise, Hawke and Frank Whaley.
– Johanna Steinmetz,
Chicago Tribune,
4 Dec 2013
fresh:
A Midnight Clear -- not quite a great war movie but certainly a sensitive, bright and supremely moral one -- shows how courage itself can be a kind of insanity.
– Michael Wilmington,
Los Angeles Times,
4 Dec 2013
rotten:
It's so determined to be haunting that it gives up the ghost.
– Michael Sragow,
New Yorker,
4 Dec 2013
fresh:
[Gordon] clearly relishes the story's many ironies, and he's often successful at sharing his enjoyment of them with us.
– Jay Boyar,
Orlando Sentinel,
4 Dec 2013
fresh:
A Midnight Clear doesn't do as much as it might with its characters. But as a parable of human folly and fragile hope, it has considerable impact.